Christmas Traditions Americans Are Ditching for 2024

Have I read correctly?
Ditching Christmas Traditions?
Is the traditional Christmas dinner becoming a thing of the past?

A recent study reveals that Americans are ready to shake up their holiday celebrations. From ditching the turkey for tacos to spending the day in pajamas, the findings show a growing trend for reinventing the holidays for more personal memories.

Breaking Away from the Old

According to the poll of 2,000 Americans who celebrate Christmas, 31% admit they’re bored of the usual festive customs. Nearly half (47%) prefer to spend the day in their pajamas, while 35% would rather focus on quality time than elaborate meals or gifts. A bold 18% even like the idea of a “friends-only” Christmas, opting for close camaraderie over extended family gatherings.

It’s not really “ditching” Christmas traditions but this growing desire for change reflects a willingness to embrace fresh ideas, making Christmas feel less like a repetitive obligation and more like a celebration tailored to modern lifestyles.

It’s not about losing the holiday spirit—it’s about refreshing it. Traditions evolve, and so should our celebrations.

Spokesperson at St Pierre Bakery

Ditching Christmas Traditions: The New Festive Feast

For those tired of turkey, 60% of respondents have already enjoyed an nontraditional meal on Christmas Day. Pizza topped the list of favorites (37%), followed by pasta (31%) and burgers (28%). In fact, half of those who opted for something different said it was more enjoyable than expected.

Here is the top 10 popular alternatives Americans want to see on their Christmas dinner tables replacing the traditional turkey:

Food plays a significant role in holiday celebrations, and many families are discovering that breaking tradition can lead to “magnifique” new memories.

Top Modern Traditions Taking Over

Beyond food, Americans are embracing creative new customs to bring the magic back into the holidays. Here is the top 10 of some modern traditions that Americans would prefer to do:

These fresh approaches allow families to focus on what matters most—connection, gratitude, and joy—while leaving behind some of the stress and commercialism often associated with the season.

Watch the Trends Come to Life

To highlight these findings, St Pierre USA created a video to showcase the key findings. Check out the video below:

It’s Time to Rethink Christmas

While nearly 70% of respondents are eager to create new customs, 62% feel obligated to follow traditional ones. However, this study shows there’s excitement about exploring unique ways to celebrate, whether it’s a tropical Christmas or an indulgent brunch.

From endless turkey dinners to familiar carols, some families are craving a fresh twist. Reigniting the holiday spirit doesn’t mean leaving traditions behind; it means making them your own.

Spokesperson at St Pierre Bakery

Whether you’re swapping turkey for tacos or writing letters instead of buying gifts, this holiday season is the perfect time to embrace modern traditions that bring joy and create cherished memories for years to come.